Southern Rhône Horizontal, Bountiful B.C., Huff of PEC, Pretty Pinots, Classy Italians and Forgotten Corners of the Old World and Lake Erie North Shore
Vintages September 4th release is the most interesting since sometime pre-summer 2010. There is certainly a seasonal pulse to the wine business, and in September as the grapes ripen, everything gets all serious again. And the overall quality at Vintages improves. I do wonder why summer should be less focused on quality, but so be it. I was delighted to encounter several 90+ wines in this release, although I must also say that there are several disappointments and ho-hum entries, particularly among New World reds that hover in Vintages favourite $15 to $18 price range.

The special Southern Rhone feature is by and large very strong; and presents an opportunity for a great learning experience. It’s range includes several different appellations, price levels and styles – all from the same, excellent 2007 vintage. If it is at all affordable I would buy one of each and re-construct this horizontal tasting I was able to do twice at the LCBO. (Vintages was kind enough to provide one very early look at the wines in time to write a column in Toronto Life appearing in the next few days). It is a fascinating frozen-in-the-moment glimpse at the evolution of French wine region; wherein some stick to the old ways, some head into international territory and others try to blend the two ideas. It is also provides a look at the emergence of smaller, less well known village appellations to challenge the old guard. The best values are certainly among these challengers, while the established regions like Chateauneuf-du-Pape and Gigondas cling to supremacy through sheer size and depth of flavour. Individually there are many good buys, so spend some time by searching WineAlign by Southern Rhone. For the wine that best shows the character, depth and the certain rustic majesty I like in the region, tryVignerons De Gigondas La Font Des Grières 2007 Gigondas.
![]()
I spent almost three weeks in British Columbia in August – ten days in Okanagan and Similkameen wine country, including five days at the Canadian Wine Awards in Penticton where I tasted hundreds of B.C. wines. And by the way, I think the overall quality is up in B.C., even since my last visit in 2008. The wines are showing better balance with less alcohol. The great lament in Ontario is that we can’t get more B.C. wine, and the reasons are classically Canadian. There is not that much B.C. wine to go around and those folks who look up and see mountains every day are drinking most of it – and who can blame them. Then there are our ridiculous inter-provincial laws that treat B.C. wines as imports in Ontario, with all the requisite listing hoops. Frankly many B.C. producers can’t muster much enthusiasm to jump through them when they are selling so well at home and in Alberta. So we must rely on spot listings at Vintages and a few regulars at the LCBO. Although the Sept 4 mini-feature is dominated by the powerful wines from Sandhill – The Canadian Wine Awards Winery of the Year in 2009 – I would like to steer you to Cedarcreek Estate 2007 Cabernet/Merlot as an example of the new elegance being crafted in the Okanagan. By the way, Darryl Brooker, formerly of Hillebrand and Flat Rock in Niagara, has taken over at Cedar Creek this year from talented California-raised winemaker Tom DiBello.
![]()
Huff Estates 2007 South Bay Chardonnay is the most decorated wine yet made in Prince Edward County. To crib from my upcoming article in County Grapevine Magazine: “The first inkling of stardom was a gold medal at the Royal Winter Fair in November 2009, followed quickly by a gold medal when it accompanied the winning recipe from Montreal’s Kitchen Galèrie at the Canadian Culinary Championships in Vancouver. It was named top chardonnay and Wine of the Year at the Ontario Wine Awards judged in April, then two days it was also voted Best White at the 2010 Artevino Wine Awards for Prince Edward County wines. At the same time, way over the pond in London, England it appeared on the fave lists of top British wine writers like Jancis Robinson during a showcase of Ontario chardonnays called Seriously Cool.” You must try this wine if for nothing else except the way it best expresses County soils. And this release is your last chance. It sold out at the winery weeks ago after the avalanche of accolades.
![]()
Every time I taste wines at Vintages I like to start my reds with pinot noir, hopping around the tasting bench among the regions where it excels – Burgundy, New Zealand, Canada, California etc – to compare them side by side. There is always just an extra sense of intrigue and fragrance that no other reds deliver. They can be so pretty and engaging. I found several pretty pinot on this release and none were outrageously priced given the quality delivered, included the two solid Burgundies. But it was Steve Bird Big Barrel 2008 Pinot Noir from the Marlborough region of New Zealand that struck me as the prettiest and best value at under $25. But pinot is always perplexing too and this time I worked very hard to come up with a rating for the Gallo 2007 Sonoma County Pinot which showed collapsed flavours when it endured long air exposure, while a fresh bottle was actually quite good.
![]()
The surprise of the release were a handful of very classy Italian reds from all three main regions – Tuscany, Piedmont and Veneto. There are four 90 or better scores among six wines, and again none are outrageously priced, nor are they from well established, iconic producers. To see this level of quality from different regions, grapes and winemakers speaks very much to the observation by many people that Italy is perhaps the most dynamic and interesting wine country in the world today. The better wines capture complexity, balance, depth and a certain sophistication that is very appealing. For example, try Tenimenti Angelini Tre Rose 2006 Vino Nobile Di Montepulciano, a wine returning to Vintages after first release last September, and still drinking with everything you might want in a maturing Tuscan sangiovese.

And for some reason this release has assembled a clutch of wines from some forgotten corners of the Old World – countries like Croatia, Morocco, Lebanon, Georgia, and Moldova. It is very nice, and very Canadian, of the LCBO to offer a window to these wines, but the shotgun approach and reticense to import anything of serious quality and price, is perhaps not the right course of action. Quality is frankly a crap shoot at this price level. There are a couple of good buys this release including 178095 Chateau 2007 Ksara Prieuré from Lebanon’s Bekaa Valley, but the wines from Croatia and Moldova are flawed enough to make me ask why they were purchased in the first place, and ask “who is this helping?” I would much rather see more serious effort by Vintages to assemble a grouping from say Lebanon or Slovenia, offer them all at once, and see what sticks long enough to build a bit of a market. By the way, I had a Chateau Musar 1999 from Lebanon last week in a Windsor restaurant called Mazaar, and I was blown away by the wine as is warmed and breathed in the glass. When we left there was one bottle left in stock.
I was in Windsor during a three day visit to the wineries of Lake Erie North Shore, which is itself something of a forgotten corner because its wines are virtually unknown from the GTA eastward. The LCBO is loaded with wines from the two largest producers: Pelee Island and Colio, but bereft of listings from new comers like Sprucewood Shores, Mastronardi, Muscedere, Colchester Ridge, Viewpointe and Smith & Wilson. Yes they do have wines in the LCBOs Go To Market program in stores from London to Windsor, but again very few are available elsewhere unless you order direct from the wineries themselves. I spent three days in LENS (as the locals call it) and can confidently predict that they will not remain forgotten for long. There are now 14 wineries in the region and a palpable local pride way down south at the 42nd parallel. I was especially impressed by the cabernet and merlot-based reds from Muscedere and Sprucewood, plus higher end wines from Pelee Island (delicious Cabernet/Petit Verdot) and Colio’s CEV line. There were also a couple of very good local syrahs. Most interesting is the fact that 2008 was actually a better red vintage in Ontario’s banana belt than 2007.
That’s it for now; happy shopping.
See all my reviews for the September 4th release here.
Cheers,
David Lawrason, VP of Wine at WineAlign
Filed under: News, Wine , Vintages, David Lawrason, Lawrasons Take, Southern Rhône, LENS















the trio of bells, the pack mules carrying building material through the narrow alleys where no cars can venture. Were it not for the hordes of tourist who disembark daily and trek up to Oia to clog those same minuscule streets and haggle with weary locals over junky trinkets, Santorini could well be a paradise on earth.
green on a natural canvas. One wonders how anything at all manages to grow in this poorest of poor soils. Closer inspection reveals that this is no purposeless vegetation; these are grapevines. But these are like no other grapevines I’ve seen. There are no posts, no wires, no trellises, no neat rows of orderly canes and leaves, made to submit by the hand of man. These vines sprawl along the ground, the stalks obscured by decades worth of woven shoots that makes them look like gnarled, old wicker baskets discarded in an empty waste yard on the backside of a middle eastern bazaar. You could easily drive past these fields and remain gleefully ignorant that you are in wine country. How strange to see, or not see. If I hadn’t seen, and tasted, I may not believe that some of the world’s most original wines are made in these vineyards on the island of Santorini.
The grape is called assyrtico, an ancient, indigenous variety that achieves its greatest expression in the poor volcanic soils of the island. Really, Santorini is nothing more than a piece of exploded volcanic mountaintop protruding from the sea, with little vegetation and no fresh water. Before its eerie beauty was discovered by outsiders and the age of tourism began, this was among the poorest of Greek Islands, the inhabitants scratching out a meager existence from the unyielding terrain.






Recent Comments